Some people have been disparaging a statistical approach to the semantics of natural language. This is essentially a kind of prejudice, as if we came from the wrong side of the technology railroad tracks. It ignores the fact that statistical approaches have performed spectacularly well in some high profile settings.
Have you ever watched the “Iron Chef” on the Food Network? This is where two competing chefs are given an ingredient kept secret until the start of the show, and each contestant then has 60 minutes to create an entire meal around that ingredient. A panel then judges and critiques the two meals and crowns a winner.
In 2003, DARPA ran its own version of “Iron Chef,” though with only a single team of collaborators from eleven academic institutions across the U.S. The team was given a language, with the task of creating a cross-language information retrieval system and a machine translation system within TEN DAYS after learning what the language actually was.
To make challenge harder, the language was not French, Arabic, or Russian, but Cebuano, a dialect spoken in the Philippines. None of the team was familiar with the language, but through the magic of Internet collaboration, they were able in ten days to collect a corpus of resources in Cebuano and English and apply statistical methods to create both a fully workable cross-language retrieval system and a credible start to a translation capability.
The two principal investigators of the Herculean exercise wrote afterward that, given what they learned in those ten days, they would do better next time. They predicted that their team could build a fully working statistical machine translation facility for a specified language in just a single day given adequate linguistic and computational resources.
In ten days, you could not build even a parser for a language that you have never heard of, much less develop the semantic mapping of that language into some kind of logical model of meaning to support cross-language search and machine translation. Statistical methods do work in semantics.